2020.2.0 Model Release / 2020 NHL Draft Roundup10.17.2020 : release, 2020
New predictions are posted for prospects that were eligible for the 2020 NHL Draft:
- CHL/USHL forwards who were eligible for the 2020 NHL draft
- CHL/USHL defensemen who were eligible for the 2020 NHL draft
- CHL/USHL/J20/MHL forwards who were eligible for the 2020 NHL draft
Obviously, the 2020 NHL Draft has come and gone, and as much as I would have liked to release this update prior to the draft, that just wasn't in the cards. The good thing is I get to write about the model output as compared to how the draft actually transpired.
The main improvement in the new model is that the input data obtained from Elite Prospects is supplemented with data scraped from CHL and USHL game summaries, for example, here's one. This allows us to use a variety of different statistics that aren't available from EP data, like primary assists, minor penalties, even-strength stats, and many more. This new data mainly contributed to the models marked 'CHL/USHL' above.
The current model release considers only prospects that were in their first year of draft eligibility for the 2020 NHL draft. To that, there is a bit of a balancing act between making predictions for as many players as possible, and maintaining model accuracy, and generally keeping things reasonable. For example, a CHL/USHL/J20/MHL/x/y model for defensemen was not provided for this release, simply because treating that diversity of leagues in the same model degrades accuracy. The underlying code can also handle overagers, but maybe that's a topic for another day.
With the logistics out of the way, let's move on to the some analysis:
High Value Picks:
There were some picks for whom the model predicts a better NHL career than their actual overall draft position might imply:
- Sam Colangelo, drafted 38th overall by the Ducks. He's been a favorite of the model all season. He's ranked as best or 2nd best forward in the draft by the model, which is probably overly optimistic. Put up a 58 point season with the Chicago Steel of the USHL.
- Seth Jarvis, drafted 13th overall. Jarvis has the 3rd highest probability to be a 1st liner out of the CHL draftees considered. Dawson Mercer (18th overall) is in a similar position.
Defense is always trickier, but here's a potential value pick or two anyway:
- Daemon Hunt, drafted 65th overall by the Minnesota Wild. According to the model, he may be a high-floor stay-at-home type guy.
There are many more picks of varying value. These were mostly obtained by sorting by the Miss Probability and First-Liner Probability columns in the model pages.
Low Value Picks:
There were also some players who the model ranked much lower than their actual draft position:
- Vasili Ponomaryov, drafted 53rd overall by the Carolina Hurricanes. The CHL/USHL model gives him only a 9% chance to make the NHL in any significant capacity.
- Cross Hanas, drafted 55th overall by the Detroit Red Wings. 15% chance to make the NHL in any significant capacity.
- Ridley Greig, drafted 28th overall by the Senators.
On balance, the model is quite good at calling negatives (relatively fewer false negatives than false positives, which makes sense since that is the nature of the NHL draft), but only time will tell.
Potentially Weak Defensemen Class:
I heard some discussion prior to the draft indicating that this year's defensemen class might not quite be up to snuff. Who knows whether or not that will turn out to be the case, but one way to at least get a grip on this is to compare the probabilities from the model output to those found in the cross-validation data (essentially probabilities from previous drafts).
Just looking at miss probabilities for the defensemen model posted above, it does appear that there aren't a whole lot of sure-things in this year's draft. There may be some inherent bias in the model that's responsible for this, but also, perhaps not, as this issue is not seen with this year's forward models.
Potential UDFA Finds:
Here's an interesting tweet:
Highest-scoring CHLers (2019-20) who went undrafted (2002 BY):— Ben Misfeldt (@BBMHockey) October 14, 2020
James Hardie- 1.07 P/GP
Kyle Crnkovic- 1.02 P/GP
Brady Burns- 0.89 P/GP
Owen Pederson- 0.82 P/GP
Theo Rochette- 0.80 P/GP
Logan Morrison- 0.76 P/GP
Reid Valade- 0.75 P/GP
Ethan Cardwell- 0.75 P/GP
Of course, points aren't everything. Here are some undrafted forwards for whom the model produced favorable probabilities:
- James Hardie, as noted above
- Stephen Halliday, big-bodied winger who scored 0.84 PPG with the Dubuque Fighting Saints of the USHL.
- Cameron Berg, a centre who seemed to benefit from a change of scenery, and scored 0.94 PPG for the Muskegon Lumberjacks of the USHL.
For defensemen, things are a little foggier owing to the underlying fogginess of the model, but there are still some players who might be worth a shot:
- Christian Jimenez, slightly undersized USHL'er, scored .66 PPG with the Sioux City Musketeers. The model can sometimes overrate offensive defensemen, maybe that's what's happened here.
- Simon Kubicek, played with the Seattle Thunderbirds of the WHL.
These players were identified by sorting by 'Miss Prob.' on the model pages and finding the first few undrafted players.
Stay healthy, and feel free to reach out on twitter.